Why? Tell me why?
There's a river to cry tonight?
Oh why?

Try, don't you try?
You can't never deny what's right
Don't you try?
Oh my

Look at me
Caught in your mystery
I'm giving twice the feeling
But I'm not receiving
Now my head is turning
And my eyes are burning
It's the truth I'm learning?
What am I to do
With two of you?

Why? Tell me why?
There's a river to cry tonight?
Oh why?

Try, don't you try?
You can't never deny what's right
Oh my

I can see
You made a fool of me
And you've been double dealing
This is so revealing
Which of you is Mary?
I can't tell it can't be
You've both been deceiving
What am I to do
With two of you?